On the night of July 20, 1969, hundreds of millions of people watched a man step onto the Moon, and almost none of them saw the picture the Moon actually sent. What reached the living room was a copy of a copy, softer than the original, and carried on a satellite web finished only weeks before. This is the story of that picture’s journey: out of a camera bolted to a lander, down to three dishes on a turning Earth, through a conversion that cost it its sharpness, and into the record of history. And it is the story of the sharper original, which a few engineers saw once and no one has seen since.
The moonwalk reached Earth from a camera no television set could play: 10 frames a second, 320 lines, against America’s 30 frames and 525 lines. Three ground stations caught the picture, and the broadcast the world watched was made by a television camera, in effect, filming a television screen. The sharper original tapes ended their journey in a records center, and they are missing to this day.
A camera no television could play
Television from space was still new. Apollo 8 had sent live pictures from lunar orbit in December 1968, and Apollo 10 carried the first color camera that May. But the camera that mattered most, the one mounted on the lunar module for the first steps, spoke a language no television on Earth could understand. Westinghouse built it to a slow-scan standard: 10 frames a second, 320 lines, against America’s 30 frames and 525 lines. It rode mounted upside down on the side of the lander, so the stations had to flip the picture. Buzz Aldrin switched it on, and the transmission began at 02:54 GMT on July 21, two minutes before the first step, which came at 10:56 in the evening, Eastern Daylight Time, on July 20 in America. The landing itself had come at 20:17 GMT.
The whole signal, voice, data and picture, left the Moon on a transmitter of about 20 watts. The camera itself drew only six and a half watts of that. The signal then took about 1.3 seconds to cross to Earth, so the world watched it live, give or take a second and a bit for the light to cross.
Three dishes, one picture
Three dishes caught the picture at once. Honeysuckle Creek near Canberra carried the first step to the world after Goldstone’s picture went out upside down, and then, about nine minutes in, the bigger Parkes dish took over for the rest of the two-and-a-half-hour walk, the choice made first in Sydney, between the two Australian pictures, and then in Houston.
The choosing had two stages, and the record credits both. In Sydney, Charlie Goodman of NASA Goddard chose between the Parkes and Honeysuckle pictures and passed the better one on to Houston. In Houston, the television controller chose between the Australian feed and Goldstone. Goldstone’s own part in the night is quickly told: Goldstone’s picture went out upside down and murky. Parkes and Goldstone were the giants of the three, their dishes 64 meters across; Honeysuckle Creek’s dish was 26 meters. At Parkes the great dish sat fully tipped at its limit, waiting for the Moon to rise into its beam, while gusts of 110 kilometers an hour slammed it against its gears, and it caught the signal first on a less sensitive off-axis feed before the main feed took over.
From Australia the picture went by satellite to Houston, and from Houston to the networks and the world. The satellite web that carried it had only been completed nineteen days earlier.
A Soviet probe, Luna 15, was in lunar orbit at the same time.
The picture the public saw
At Goldstone and Honeysuckle Creek the conversion was done on site, and for Parkes it was done in Sydney. The slow-scan picture could not go out as it arrived. It was shown on a high-quality monitor, ten inches across, and a conventional broadcast camera filmed that monitor, while a disc recorder repeated fields to build the thirty frames a second that television sets expected. The world, in other words, watched a television camera, in effect, filming a television screen.
The conversion cost the picture dearly. The few engineers watching the raw monitors saw a sharper, cleaner moonwalk than anyone at home. In Houston’s television laboratory, Stan Lebar watched the converted picture arrive, and told NPR in 2006 that it “was being degraded something awful.”
There had been no picture at all for the landing itself. The surface camera came on only at the start of the moonwalk, so during the descent the networks filled their screens with animations and simulations while the anchors talked, and the audience listened to the voices from the Moon. The three American networks stayed with the story continuously, and the three networks spent, by one estimate, around $11 million. In Britain, the BBC and ITV both stayed on the air for eleven hours, British television’s first all-night broadcast, with Cliff Michelmore, James Burke, and Patrick Moore at the BBC desk.
How many people watched
Nobody knows the count, and the honest answer is the disagreement. Estimates run from 500 to 650 million. The highest of those figures was the US Information Agency’s own estimate in 1969, reported to President Nixon in a memo that put 500 million of the watchers abroad. Set against a world of about 3.6 billion people, the audience was roughly one person in six alive. In the United States, by the commonly cited Nielsen figure, 94 percent of American sets in use were tuned to the landing. President Nixon had proclaimed July 21 a National Day of Participation and closed the federal agencies for it, and the US Information Agency worked to put the landing in front of audiences abroad.
Not everywhere saw it happen live. The Soviet Union showed it only later, in its newscasts; China not at all live.
The sharper moon, lost
The stations had recorded what their dishes heard, raw, before the conversion: about 45 reels of one-inch tape across the three stations. Those tapes were the sharp moonwalk, the one the engineers saw. NASA shipped them to the Goddard Space Flight Center, and from there to the Washington National Records Center at Suitland, Maryland, where they entered the National Archives in 1970 in Accession 69A4099. By 1984, all but two of the more than 700 boxes of Apollo-era tapes in that accession had been withdrawn. The moonwalk tapes were never seen again.
When reporting in 2006 raised the question of where they had gone, NASA searched for three years. Hopes rose more than once and came to nothing. Even a tape kept in an engineer’s garage, when tested, turned out not to be the moonwalk. NASA concluded the tapes were almost certainly wiped and reused, among some 200,000 recycled. The final report of 2009 closed the search: the slow-scan recordings no longer exist. What survives is the converted picture, restored in 2009 by Lowry Digital from the best copies that remain, the CBS News archive, the kinescopes kept at the Johnson Space Center, and recordings made in Australia. When we watch the first step today, we watch the copy, cleaned and steadied, of a sharper original that is missing.
Where the past meets the present
The most watched moment of the twentieth century survives only in its degraded form. The sharper moonwalk was real; a few dozen engineers saw it on their monitors that night, and the record of it is now a file of reports about its loss. The copy outlived the original because the copy was the one that got sent out, copied again, and kept in a dozen places, while the original sat in one records center, in boxes that looked like every other box of tape in a shortage.
Carry this with you: what history keeps of a great moment is not always the best version that existed; sometimes it is only the version that happened to be shared. What in your own family’s past now survives only as a copy, a retelling, a photograph of a photograph, and what would the original show that the copy cannot?
Sources
NASA, The Apollo 11 Telemetry Data Recordings: A Final Report (2009): https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/static/history/alsj/a11/Apollo_11_TV_Tapes_Report.pdf
NASA ALSJ, Apollo 11 TV comparisons (Goldstone, Honeysuckle, Parkes, Houston): http://www.honeysucklecreek.net/Apollo_11/Apollo_11_TV_comparisons.pdf
J. Sarkissian, The Search for the Apollo 11 SSTV Tapes (CSIRO Parkes, 2006): https://www.parkes.atnf.csiro.au/news_events/apollo11/The_Apollo11_SSTV_Tapes_Search.pdf
CSIRO Parkes, Apollo 11 TV broadcasts: https://www.parkes.atnf.csiro.au/news_events/apollo11/tv_broadcasts.html
CSIRO ATNF, The Dish: Fact versus Fiction: https://www.atnf.csiro.au/outreach/visiting/parkes/looselybased.html
USIA Director to President Nixon, 1969 (Foreign Relations of the United States, Public Diplomacy vol. VIII, doc. 29): https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1917-72PubDipv08/d29
Proclamation 3919, National Day of Participation (American Presidency Project): https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/proclamation-3919-national-day-participation-honoring-the-apollo-11-mission
NPR, “Search Is on for Original Apollo 11 Footage” (July 31, 2006): https://www.npr.org/2006/07/31/5578853/search-is-on-for-original-apollo-11-footage
NPR, “Houston, We Erased The Apollo 11 Tapes” (July 16, 2009): https://www.npr.org/2009/07/16/106637066/houston-we-erased-the-apollo-11-tapes
Sky & Telescope, “How Earth saw Apollo 11’s first steps”: https://skyandtelescope.org/astronomy-news/how-earth-saw-apollo-11-first-steps/
National Science and Media Museum, “How the UK watched the Apollo 11 Moon landing”: https://blog.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/how-the-uk-watched-the-apollo-11-moon-landing
Enjoyed this story?
Get one like it every week — plus our free 10 Turning Points timeline.