Skip to main content

Timeless Medium

The People Who Built the World Beneath Our Feet

Read Time:8 Minute, 36 Second

Deep beneath a town in Cappadocia, in what is now Turkey, there is a stone door: round, heavy, and made to be rolled shut from the inside. Whoever closed it meant to stay hidden, and to stay alive.

People built whole worlds under their own streets, and we call them underground cities. But were they cities? This story puts that question to the most famous of them, and to a few of the least famous. The builders get the first word. The question gets the last.

The famous underground cities were refuges, not cities: nobody lived in them for good, and when the danger passed, people climbed back up and went home. The only places in this story where people truly lived underground for good were Coober Pedy in Australia and Matmata in Tunisia, and what their families built were a town and a village, not cities.

The Test

A city, as this story uses the word, is a place where people live for good: homes slept in every night, food stored, water drawn, waste carried away, worship, work, trade, and some order over it all. Fail the staying test, and a place may be remarkable, but it is not a city. One more rule, in honesty: the record rarely names the first diggers, so no one here is crowned the inventor of the underground city.

Hiding: Derinkuyu

At Derinkuyu, no builder's name survives. Communities cut the soft volcanic rock by hand over centuries, and the work is their biography. Stables and stores sit near the top; below are living rooms, presses, cellars, dining halls, and chapels, in the order visitors see in the tenth of the place that is open. The heavy doors were rolled shut from the inside. It reaches about 85 metres down, and at least one deep ventilation shaft doubled as a well. Estimates often say 20,000 people could shelter here with their animals, though no one counted them.

Turkey's own official sources disagree about when it began. One Ministry page dates the city as we know it to the 9th to 10th centuries; tourism writing credits the Phrygians with the first cutting, but that is a claim, not a dating. One honest blank remains: how thousands of people dealt with waste down here is something the records do not tell us.

Derinkuyu was a refuge built to the scale of a small city. But nobody lived there for good, and a refuge is a place people leave.

Hiding: Kaymakli, and a Witness

Kaymakli, not far away, is the sister refuge: wider, shallower, cut for the same reason, able to shelter thousands while danger lasted. People say a tunnel joins the two places; if it does, no one has opened it to show. What these refuges could do, we know because a witness wrote it down.

A Primary Source: Dawkins at Axo, 1909

In 1909, the Cambridge scholar R. M. Dawkins was working in Cappadocia when news arrived of the massacres at Adana. In Modern Greek in Asia Minor, published in 1916, he recorded that at Axo, a village with underground chambers of its own, a great part of the population took refuge in them, and for some nights no one ventured to sleep above ground.

It is the best single piece of evidence in this story, because it is measured in nights. Hiding worked for a thousand years, and every time, when the danger passed, the people climbed back up and went home.

Living: Coober Pedy

The next place is full of names. In 1915, in the South Australian desert, Willie Hutchison, fourteen years old, found opal. That same year, Jim and Dick O'Neill and their friend Fred Blakeley dug the field's first dugout. After the war, returned soldiers who knew trench life made the idea a town.

Nobody here was hiding. The enemy was the heat: summers regularly past 40 degrees, while underground the temperature barely moves. Families dug their own homes, and still extend them room by room. By most estimates, about half the town lives underground.

The hard problem was water. A great underground tank was built in 1922. In 1966, a solar still covering almost two acres began turning brackish bore water into drinking water; since 1985, a reverse osmosis plant has treated artesian bore water. Coober Pedy passes test after test: a real, permanent town whose homes are underground. Only its size argues with the word city, and town is the honest word.

Living: Matmata

In Tunisia, the builders were households. At Matmata, a family started by digging a pit about 10 metres down, which became an open-air courtyard; rooms were cut sideways into its walls, for living, storage, stables, and an olive press. An eyewitness described the method in 1909, and Tunisia's account to UNESCO describes the same layout. The knowledge passed down inside Amazigh families. There is no architect to name, and no provable founding date. The purpose was shelter from fierce heat and cold, in a region that knew raids and insecurity.

Permanence was proved the hard way. After the floods of 1969 the government built a new town above ground. Some families moved; others repaired their homes and stayed. Over the decades, most have left. Matmata is a real, permanent village of true underground homes: a village, not a city, and a complete answer in itself.

Built by Accident: Seattle and Edinburgh

Some underground places were never meant to be underground. When fire burned about thirty blocks of Seattle on June 6, 1889, the city raised its streets: crews built retaining walls, filled between them, and paved a new street one to two storeys up. Merchants who had rebuilt at the old grade found their ground floors below the sidewalk, and in 1907 the city sealed the old spaces off over public health fears. Nobody designed an underground. The city rose, and its ground floor was left behind.

In Edinburgh, the Royal Exchange was built over the close in 1753, keeping its lower levels as foundations. The close took its name from Mary King, a merchant and burgess of the 1600s who is believed to have lived there; she built none of it. The last resident, a sawmaker named Andrew Chesney, left in 1902. The famous story that plague victims were walled up alive in the close is just that, a story. Nearby, the South Bridge Vaults hold more than a hundred chambers built inside a bridge from 1785 to 1788. They began as workshops for taverns, cobblers, and cutlers; their builders never waterproofed them, the trades drifted away, and the city's poorest moved in.

Systems, Not Cities

Under Chicago, a telephone company dug a railway. The Illinois Telephone and Telegraph Company began it in 1899; it became the Illinois Tunnel Company in 1905, and the Chicago Tunnel Company in 1912. Carrying freight from 1906, it ran about 60 miles of narrow-gauge electric line, some 40 feet below the streets, and served the city above for decades. Nobody ever lived in it.

Helsinki planned its depths instead. The city's own Geotechnical Division designed its rock tunnels and underground works; the Paijanne water tunnel, about 120 kilometres long, was finished in 1982; shelters have been built from 1955 onward, and there are now hundreds of underground premises. In 2010 it became one of the first cities to approve a master plan for everything beneath its whole territory: a real city's working basement and shelter, with no underground residents at all.

Montreal's RESO began with one planner, Vincent Ponte, and Place Ville Marie in 1962; the Bonaventure link was in place by 1967, in time for Expo 67. Then it grew piece by piece, with no master plan. It is, by Guinness World Records' measure, the largest underground pedestrian network in the world. A network inside a city is not a city, and much of it is not even underground.

What to Carry With You

So were underground cities really cities? The refuges were not, because nobody stayed. The buried streets were never underground by design. The tunnels and networks serve cities without being cities. The only people who truly lived beneath the surface for good were families, in a desert town and a village, and a town and a village are what they built.

Carry this with you. A city is not measured by how deep it goes, or how well it hides. It is measured by whether people stay, and build a life, and hand the digging on. The people beneath our feet did all of that, in the dark, mostly without leaving their names. The work remembers them.

Sources

  • Dawkins, R. M., Modern Greek in Asia Minor, Cambridge University Press, 1916.
  • Republic of Turkiye Ministry of Culture and Tourism, and Turkish Museums, pages on the Derinkuyu and Kaymakli underground cities.
  • Truman, G., "Turkey's underground city of 20,000 people," BBC Travel, 2022.
  • Coober Pedy Historical Society, "Timeline," cooberpedyhistoricalsociety.org.au.
  • Australian Centre for the Moving Image, "Water from the Sun" (CSIRO, 1967), on the solar still constructed in 1966.
  • Parliament of South Australia, Hansard, Legislative Council, March 23, 2011.
  • Bayet, M., "Les troglodytes de l'Extreme-Sud tunisien," Bulletin de la Societe d'Anthropologie de Bruxelles, 1909.
  • Permanent Delegation of Tunisia, UNESCO Tentative List submission on troglodyte habitat in southern Tunisia, 2020.
  • Al Jazeera, "The last residents of Tunisia's underground houses," February 27, 2018.
  • Caldbick, J., "The Great Seattle Fire," HistoryLink.org, Essay 21099.
  • Historic Environment Scotland, Canmore records for Mary King's Close, the City Chambers, and South Bridge, Edinburgh.
  • Vahaaho, I., Urban Underground Space: Sustainable Property Development in Helsinki, City of Helsinki, 2014.
  • McGill University Library, archival collections record for Vincent Ponte.
  • Ville de Montreal, "RESO, le reseau souterrain de Montreal," montreal.ca.
  • Guinness World Records, "Largest pedestrian subway network."
  • Encyclopedia of Chicago, "Tunnels," Chicago Historical Society and Newberry Library.

Discussion Question

Which of these places would you call a city, and what settles it for you?

Enjoyed this story?

Get one like it every week — plus our free 10 Turning Points timeline.

Facts verified against the sources listed above, October 2026.

Previous post The Transistor’s First Job Was a Hearing Aid
Next post The Moonwalk the World Saw Was a Copy of a Copy